- Missing My Posts? August 23, 2014
- 1274 August 4, 2014
- I have migrated!! August 3, 2014
- Monthly Book Round-up: July 2014 August 1, 2014
- Miss Peregrine’s Home For Peculiar Children | Book Review July 31, 2014
Please visit www.booksaremything.com to continue following my blog!
I thought long and hard about this post. I’ve yet to write a DNF since starting this blog. Some bloggers never write posts about the books they didn’t finish, but I don’t think that’s fair to our readers. Not only does it lead them to believe we finish every single book we read, but that also means we are leaving out some of the most important reviews we could write: the critical ones. It’s my opinion that my readers should know about books I don’t finish, and WHY I didn’t finish them, so that they can make an informed decision about whether or not they want to read it themselves.
I honestly was really apprehensive about accepting this ARC for review, and I think in the future I need to go with my gut more. The premise sounded interesting, but I wasn’t sure if I’d have the time to dedicate to such a long book. However, I found myself one afternoon away from home, messing around on my phone, and decided to check it out.
I began having a hard time right at the beginning of this book. I get that the whole plot is about language, but the opulent use of obscure words had me skimming entire paragraphs at times. It may be playing to your storyline, but if the reader is constantly having to look up words or deciding NOT to look up words and thus not entirely understanding the story, then it sort of defeats the purpose.
I found the footnotes located at the end of the chapters jarring. As I read them, I had to reference back through that chapter, which is not NEARLY as easy with an electronic copy. I truthfully skipped most of the referencing back. Mind you, I AM a scientist, so reading through footnotes isn’t unusual for me (hello research papers), I just found it weird to have in this book. If the footnotes had been inserted throughout the chapter, it may have flowed better.
The jump in perspective from chapter A (Anana’s perspective) to chapter B (Bart’s perspective), also felt strange. I think the author wanted to explain all the backstory about these two characters. The problem is that you don’t get a ton of backstory about Anana in the first chapter, that comes later, but in Chapter B you get bombarded with information, a lot of it seemingly unnecessary, at least from as far as I read.
Speaking of Anana’s backstory, you do start to get some of it in Chapter C, but it’s jumbling with various flashbacks. The Alice in Wonderland references really confused me as to how they played a part in the plot, beyond giving Anana a code name. Chapter C has all kinds of crazy things going on, the order of events is so confusing. When Anana found the secret room with all the mindless workers, I pretty much threw up my hands and decided I was done at the end of the chapter. It just didn’t make sense with what had happened so far. I felt like 5,000 questions had been brought up with absolutely no answers.
Chapter D ended at roughly 25% of the way through the book. I decided I had given the book it’s due diligence, and wasn’t going to punish myself any further. The author’s ideas for this book were great ones, just poorly executed. Someone with a love of words and dystopian novels, willing to push through the confusing slog of the beginning, *might* like this one. Though given I only read a quarter of it, they may not.
Some women collect shoes, others collect purses. I collect books.
When You Just Need Spoiler-Free Reviews In A Pinch
“Let food be your medicine and your medicine be your food” – Hippocrates
musings of a teacher, parent, and life-long learner
“Books to the ceiling, Books to the sky, My pile of books is a mile high. How I love them! How I need them! I'll have a long beard by the time I read them.” - Arnold Lobel
Reading without reflecting is like eating without digesting - Edmund Burke
A topnotch WordPress.com site
What's the dirt on soil? Find out here.